This space has gone after David Miller in the past for his bromidic, casually ideological and often contradictory pronouncements on various issues. When Toronto spent untold extra moneys to ensure its new subway cars would be made in Thunder Bay, rather than by beastly Germans or Koreans, he told a union crowd that he was “shocked, utterly shocked as a Torontonian, as a proud Canadian and as the mayor of Toronto, that there’s even an argument about this.”
“If I as mayor stood up and said ‘We’re going to take $500 million from the federal government and the provincial government and we’re not going to use it to create jobs in Ontario - we’re going to use it to create jobs in China’ - the federal and provincial governments would never give us another nickel for public transit,” he elaborated. This as Vancouver waited eagerly for its Korean trains, and Edmonton for its German ones. This while Thunder Bay’s Bombardier plant built rolling stock for cities around the world.
Mere months after Miller issued his convenient manifesto for municipal federalism, he declared his support for allowing non-citizens to vote in municipal elections on the grounds that they have no significance outside city limits. “It’s not like a national election; you’re not determining issues of what this country should do or shouldn’t do,” he said.
Recently we saw this most dedicated believer in “root causes” urban crime-fighting immediately blame American guns for the death of a Toronto teenager at his high school. And last week, we saw Miller declare his disquiet with the larger, potentially pro-war message “support the troops” ribbons carry with them when you stick them on the city’s emergency vehicles.
Now, even if these ribbons unequivocally indicated political support for the Afghanistan mission, it would be a little odd for Miller to object to the fire fighters’ union purchasing them and affixing them to their trucks. Making political statements that have little or nothing to do with the rank-and-file is something that good Canadian unions do, after all.
But with their abrupt change of heart this week, Miller and various city councilors pretty much shat in logic’s bed. Presumably their misgivings about the war have something to do with Canadian casualties. We know their opposition to the ribbons is based on the idea they might indicate support for the mission, rather than simply the troops themselves. And yet having learned that the mission had resulted in three more Canadian deaths, they voted for the ribbons! This after Miller and others had insisted the stickers were only supposed to be there for a year anyway!
This is the stuff that weakens reputations, or it would be if anyone here gave a crap about these contradictions, or Afghanistan for that matter - and pretty much no one in Toronto does. Bromidic, casually ideological statements will do quite nicely, thank you very much. I’m convinced this city will vote in 50 more mayors based on pie-in-the-sky waterfront redevelopment scenarios before it’ll install one with a feasible plan that includes a tiny little airport in the middle of it, let alone a tiny little bridge to afford easier access to the tiny little airport.
Last night, a 14-year-old was stabbed in salubrious midtown Toronto, apparently because he wanted to sever ties with a gang. In the interests of consistency, David Miller should by now be declaring war on knife manufacturers.
I won’t wait up.